Decennial Liability Insurance & Subrogation

Question:
If the employer has its Decennial Liability (DL) insurance and the insurer indemnified him, can the insurer assert a subrogation claim against the builder and the consultants? Can the employer agree to waive subrogation, or to add the builder and consultants as additional insureds under the employer's insurance policy? 

My answer:
Simply speaking, DL is a public policy matter that cannot be waived by agreement. DL theory is aimed to protect the society more that the employer itself. Employer's agreement with its insurance company to waive subrogation is in effect a waiver of DL which will highly unlikely be allowed in court. The second option , i.e. adding the consultant/contractor as an additional insured, leads to the same consequences. It will prevent subrogation without having to expressly agree on the waiver of subrogation. It may work as it is similar to the case where a contractor/consultant purchases its own DL insurance policy. Basically, there is nothing preventing contractors and/or consultants from procuring an insurance policy against their DL. Such insurance is usually expensive and raises the costs sharply. DL lasts for 10 years and I wonder if such an insurance can easily be obtained...

Comments

Post a Comment

You may comment here

Popular posts from this blog

Is Online Arbitration available under the UAE Law?

Is Online Arbitration available under the UAE Law? Online arbitration covers all stages of arbitration, including the exchange of statements, the several types of hearing and notification. The new UAE Arbitration Law, Federal Law 6/2018), expanded the use of electronic technology in Arbitration. It starts with the use of electronic emails for the purpose of writing the arbitration agreement (Article 7/2).   Arbitrators tend to accept electronic submissions alone with no need for print copies. In order to avoid any unfavourable legal consequences, they tend to get the parties to agree on this approach and/or include it in their first procedural order. Personally, I prefer electronic copies of statements as I can access them anywhere and at any time. I can also search through the documents easily and swiftly.   As for the online hearing, the new law made it clear that online hearing is possible unless it is precluded by the agreement of the parties. Article (28/2) states...
Read more

Vicarious performance and Privity in Construction Contracts

Vicarious performance is quite common in construction projects. Vicarious performance refers to the performance of contract or part of it by a third party. It is quite rare for contractors to perform construction contracts without receiving help from specialized subcontractors especially in cases of purpose-built premises such as hospitals, factories, etc. Such projects require diversity of expertise that one contractor rarely acquires. Construction projects are known for their multi-contractual relations. Under the traditional construction procurement, employers start by signing a service agreement with an architect or designing engineer. The latter prepares the drawings, specifications, bill of quantities and any other particular documents. The tender process starts with the help of the engineer who may have a significant role in selecting the right contractor for the project. The employer will then sign a construction contract with the contractor who will likely subcontract part...
Read more

The legal effect of Covid-19 (Coronavirus Pandemic) on Construction Contracts under UAE Law

During the Covid-19 Pandemic, some construction projects experienced interruptions or slowing in the pace of progress. Others were suspended or terminated. Naturally, the question here becomes about the legal consequences.  Under UAE Civil Law, there are some articles that are helpful. I am quoting them below. Covid-19 may be classified as a force majeure case. It was not foreseeable at the time of making the contract and it affects all our life aspects. If, as a result, all or part of a project is terminated, articles 273 & 893 will apply. The contract will be set aside and the contractor will be entitled to the value of the work which he has completed and the expenses he has incurred in the performance thereof up to the amount of the benefit the employer has derived therefrom. Obviously, the contractor will be entitled to be only paid up to the value of the benefit conferred on the employer . The contractor will not be able to claim compensation for its losses as th...
Read more